Peppermint Brownie Cookies: A Winter Favorite You’ll Bake Again and Again

The holidays in my family have always been defined by the scent of chocolate baking and the crisp scent of peppermint floating through the house. One chilly December afternoon, my daughter and I baked our first batch of peppermint brownie cookies—a spontaneous treat after a snowball fight. We had no idea that combining rich cocoa with crushed peppermint candies would become our signature cookie for every Christmas to come. That moment inspired more than just dessert—it started a tradition.

This article dives into the ultimate recipe for peppermint brownie cookies and explores their appeal, tips for making them perfect, and fun variations to keep your holiday baking exciting. We’ll also share smart ingredient swaps, how to gift them beautifully, and much more. Expect rich flavors, crisp edges, gooey centers, and the kind of festive bite that makes winter magical.

Why Peppermint Brownie Cookies Are Your Holiday Hero

The Irresistible Flavor Duo of Chocolate and Peppermint

Peppermint brownie cookies bring together two classic holiday flavors that instantly spark nostalgia—cool peppermint and deep chocolate. It’s not just about taste—it’s the feeling you get with each bite. Imagine a cookie that’s fudgy in the middle like a brownie, slightly crisp on the edges, and studded with peppermint candy crunch. That’s the magic these cookies deliver.

They’re more than a dessert—they’re a festive experience. Every year, more bakers are turning to this flavor duo for cookie exchanges, gifting, and cozy family nights. What’s even better? These peppermint brownie cookies freeze beautifully, meaning you can prep ahead for busy holiday weeks.

To make your treat table even more festive, pair these with gingerbread crinkle cookies or serve them beside raspberry linzer cookies for a colorful cookie platter that impresses every guest.

Print

Perfect Texture: A Brownie Disguised as a Cookie

There’s a reason why these cookies earn repeat appearances on December baking lists. Texture-wise, peppermint brownie cookies check every box. Their chewy centers mimic a brownie’s rich softness, while the edges offer a delicate crunch. The peppermint? It’s not just garnish—it melts slightly into the surface during baking, giving you a burst of flavor with every bite.

If you’ve ever wondered why some cookies stay soft and others turn dry, it comes down to moisture retention from ingredients like brown sugar and melted chocolate. This recipe nails that balance. Plus, baking them just until set gives you that signature brownie interior. Serve them warm for gooey centers or let them cool for a firm bite.

Pair them with soft Danish butter cookies or a cup of peppermint cocoa for the ultimate cozy combo.

Secrets to Baking the Best Peppermint Brownie Cookies

Ingredient Quality Makes All the Difference

It’s tempting to grab whatever cocoa and extract you have on hand, but using high-quality ingredients truly elevates peppermint brownie cookies from “good” to “sensational.” Opt for Dutch-processed cocoa for a deep chocolate flavor and real peppermint extract—not imitation—for that crisp minty finish.

Fresh eggs, room temperature butter, and the right flour ratio keep the texture consistent. And don’t underestimate the power of chopped dark chocolate in addition to cocoa—it enhances the fudginess like no other.

For a dessert table that wows, serve your cookies next to traditional chocolate yule log or go for fun holiday flair with Christmas tree spinach dip breadsticks.

Chill Time Equals Thick Cookies

If there’s one baking secret that transforms peppermint brownie cookies, it’s chilling the dough. Just 30 minutes in the fridge allows the fats to solidify, helping the cookies bake up thick instead of flat. That chew you love in brownies? It’s built during this step.

Don’t skip it—plan ahead. Make your dough the night before and bake fresh in the morning. The flavors intensify overnight, giving you a richer, deeper cocoa taste and a perfectly balanced peppermint profile.

To prep for gatherings or cookie swaps, consider adding salted caramel apple crumble bars for a non-chocolate balance or whip up strawberry Santas for a playful dessert table.

Variations to Keep the Classic Cookie Exciting

Add Holiday Flair with Mix-Ins

The base recipe for peppermint brownie cookies is already irresistible, but small tweaks add personality. Stir in crushed peppermint bark, mini marshmallows, or even a swirl of white chocolate. Want an extra kick? A touch of espresso powder deepens the chocolate and adds an almost mocha-like richness.

Mini chocolate chips or crushed candy canes folded into the dough boost both flavor and texture. A simple white chocolate drizzle post-baking makes these cookies gift-worthy with very little effort.

Want to build a complete cookie box? Include cannoli cookies or go retro with little Debbie Christmas tree cake truffles for a festive variety.

Make Them Vegan or Gluten-Free

Hosting guests with dietary preferences? Peppermint brownie cookies adapt well. Swap regular butter for plant-based butter sticks and use a flax egg (1 tbsp flaxseed + 2.5 tbsp water) for an egg-free version. Use a reliable gluten-free flour blend to create the same chewy texture without compromise.

The trick with vegan baking is keeping the dough moist—add a tablespoon of non-dairy milk if needed. Gluten-free bakers may prefer to use almond flour for extra chewiness, paired with arrowroot or cornstarch to mimic wheat’s elasticity.

Round out your allergy-friendly options with soft Christmas peppermints or a slice of buttery croissant strata made with gluten-free bread for a savory counterpoint.

Turn Peppermint Brownie Cookies Into the Perfect Gift

Wrap and Present with Style

A warm batch of peppermint brownie cookies wrapped in cellophane bags and tied with red twine can brighten anyone’s day. But presentation doesn’t have to stop there. Stack cookies in holiday tins with tissue paper or layer in a mason jar with a tag for a charming, homemade touch.

Use parchment paper to separate cookie layers and consider a festive label with baking date and ingredients if gifting to friends with allergies. A personal note with the story behind these peppermint brownie cookies adds warmth that even the most expensive gift can’t match.

Impress cookie lovers even more by pairing your gifts with lemon brownies or sweet surprises like honey peach cream cheese cupcakes for variety.

Store Them for Long-Lasting Flavor

These cookies are freezer-friendly and can last up to three months. Let them cool fully before placing in airtight containers or zip-top freezer bags. To serve, just thaw at room temperature or pop into a warm oven for five minutes to refresh their softness.

Stored at room temperature, peppermint brownie cookies stay fresh for up to a week in sealed containers. Separate layers with wax paper to avoid sticking, especially if you’ve used a chocolate drizzle.

For snack trays or casual dessert nights, serve them alongside almond butter chocolate chip cookies or coffee cake for a comforting cookie-and-coffee pairing.

Serving Up the Final Words

Peppermint brownie cookies aren’t just another holiday dessert—they’re a memory in the making. They’re the kind of cookie that leaves crumbs on sweaters, chocolate smudges on fingers, and smiles across every table. Whether you’re baking for a cozy night in, a festive cookie exchange, or a thoughtful homemade gift, this recipe delivers every time.

With their chewy brownie-like centers, refreshing peppermint flair, and incredible versatility, peppermint brownie cookies deserve a spot in your baking traditions. And once you master this recipe, you’ll be passing it down just like your grandma’s sugar cookies—because holiday magic is better when shared.

FAQs About Peppermint Brownie Cookies